PDA

View Full Version : Substitute teacher tapes unruly students to chairs


WayzUp
03-03-2007, 08:58 AM
Students taped to chairs by substitute
Jefferson County bans teacher after Scotch tape used on 4th graders
Wednesday, February 28, 2007
RAHKIA NANCE
News staff writer

A substitute teacher was banned Tuesday from working in Jefferson County schools, one day after she taped a student's mouth shut and bound four other students to their seats at Pleasant Grove Elementary School.

The woman, whose name school officials declined to release, was substitute teaching in a fourth-grade classroom Monday when the incident happened.

"I don't know what keyed this, but (the taping) was done as a disciplinary action," said Nez Calhoun, a spokeswoman for the district.

Calhoun said the woman told the students to raise their arms and then bound them to their chairs with Scotch tape.

A Pleasant Grove Elementary teacher whose child was in the class alerted Principal Jay Jacks. News of the incident reached parents, who were upset.

"When I asked my son about it, he immediately started to cry," said Stacey Walker, whose son's mouth was taped shut. She said her son is asthmatic and also takes medication for attention deficit disorder.

"If he needed discipline, send them to the office. Don't tape his mouth shut," Walker said.

She said her son was reticent about the incident, fearing he would be in trouble.

"I was mad," said Angela Anderson, whose daughter was taped to her seat. Anderson said the substitute teacher also bound her daughter's legs together with tape. "If I had tied my daughter up, they would have called DHR on me."

Anderson said the students were bound for the majority of a class period, which lasts 45 minutes to an hour.

Jacks called an emergency staff meeting Monday afternoon and met with parents of four of the five students involved Tuesday morning. He said the fourth-grade class was doing fine Tuesday.

"I met with them this morning and let them know they're safe here at the school, and if there's anything they want to talk to us about, they can," he said.

Jacks said this is the first time an incident like this has happened in the four years he has been principal at the school. Calhoun said she could not think of any similar incidents in the district.

"This is certainly not the way we do discipline in the county schools," Calhoun said.

No criminal charges were filed against the woman.
Article linkage (http://www.al.com/news/birminghamnews/index.ssf?/base/news/11726544423410.xml&coll=2#continue)

gatorunvrsty
03-03-2007, 09:15 AM
That's outrageous! There may have been no criminal charges filed, but you can bet there are some parents and ruthless lawyers with dollar signs in their eyes. I think there'll be a civil suit. The teacher should definitely have just sent the unruly kids to the office. However, teachers are finding themselves in increasingly difficult positions; because many parents these days expect the schools to not only educate their children, but teach all the things that are a parent's responsibility. Discipline starts at home. Many parents are just dumping off their kids, and saying, "fix them.".

WayzUp
03-03-2007, 09:35 AM
^Agreed. I pay to send my little girl to Catholic school to avoid shtuff like this; not to say that ever public school has subs out there taping students' mouths shut and/or to their chairs for 45 minute stretches but the difference you can see just by doing a walk-through tour of both (which I HIGHLY recommend, BTW) makes that a very easy decision for me. I'm not all that religious of a person but Catholic/private schools, IMO, are the way to go.

Seppeh
03-03-2007, 09:37 AM
^Agreed. I pay to send my little girl to Catholic school to avoid shtuff like this; not to say that ever public school has subs out there taping students' mouths shut and/or to their chairs for 45 minute stretches but the difference you can see just by doing a walk-through tour of both (which I HIGHLY recommend, BTW) makes that a very easy decision for me. I'm not all that religious of a person but Catholic/private schools, IMO, are the way to go.

Public school rocks.

WayzUp
03-03-2007, 09:52 AM
Public school rocks.

They don't up here for the most part....way too few good teachers, way too may students per teacher ratio, the food is stuff I wouldn't eat (and I'll eat ANYTHING) and the resources for stuff like regular school supplies are getting thinner & thinner every passing year. I went to public school myself but that same school is nothing like it was when I went there....maybe when my kids are at the high school level, we'll send them to public schools but they're going to have to show me that education is more important than the budget bottom line for me to think about it at this point. Maybe it's different down south but budget cuts & teacher layoffs in the public schools up here has definitely had an impact on the quality of education kids receive at them.

gatorunvrsty
03-03-2007, 09:59 AM
Public school rocks.

Yeah. I know you can always GET some rocks at them. The public school system in the South is deplorable. They consistently rank at the very bottom in the country. Public high school education in the South is the anus of the entire system body, with a few (very few) exceptions.

Seppeh
03-03-2007, 10:16 AM
Yeah. I know you can always GET some rocks at them. The public school system in the South is deplorable. They consistently rank at the very bottom in the country. Public high school education in the South is the anus of the entire system body, with a few (very few) exceptions.

Then I suppose its a good thing I dont go to school down there.

gatorunvrsty
03-03-2007, 11:04 AM
Then I suppose its a good thing I dont go to school down there.

:laugh: Yeah, if you did, you might not actually be able to be a member of the forum. Reading and writing are vital for participation; although we've had some try who were barely able to do either. Of course, they didn't stay around very long. BTW, what state are you in?

Seppeh
03-03-2007, 11:16 AM
Iowa unfortunatley. :(

gatorunvrsty
03-03-2007, 11:43 AM
Iowa unfortunatley. :(

Do me a favor, and remind them who they played in the '06 Outback Bowl if they ever give you a hard time about the SEC. We beat them 31-24.:thumpsup:

WayzUp
03-03-2007, 11:51 AM
Do me a favor, and remind them who they played in the '06 Outback Bowl if they ever give you a hard time about the SEC. We beat them 31-24.:thumpsup:

They'll just bring up the LSU game from the year before that(?) when they won on the last play of the game. My mom, dad & sister along with half of my extended family are Hawkeyes.

BamaDude06
03-03-2007, 12:02 PM
Public school rocks.

Even better when you went to Pleasant Grove Elementary School. :glare:

Noah.Dreams
03-03-2007, 03:19 PM
Public high school education in the South is the anus of the entire system body, with a few (very few) exceptions.

Check out the 15 high schools in North Fulton and West Cobb counties and you'll change your mind. For the last five years, their average SAT score is around 1500.

The times they are a changin'...

But back to the original story. Silence is golden, but duct tape is silver.