GatorNation
12-12-2006, 08:42 AM
Got this off the premium boards. Schlabach really defends the SEC well. Tough questions...mostly geared to Florida/OSU, but there are some good nuggets about the SEC vs. Big 10 battle that is all the rage these days.
________________
Welcome to The Show! On Monday, ESPN.com's college football reporter Mark Schlabach will stop by to take your questions on the college gridiron. Schlabach joined ESPN.com in July 2006 as a college football and basketball columnist. A graduate of the University of Georgia, Mark spent nine years at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution covering Georgia and the SEC, as well as the NFL and NASCAR. Before joining ESPN, Schlabach spent the last two years at the Washington Post covering college football and basketball, and boxing.
Send your questions now and join Schlabach in The Show at 3 p.m. ET on Monday.
Mark Schlabach: OK, here we go. I'm sure we've got plenty to talk about today.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bruce (Greensboro, NC): I would like for you to comment on something. Last night, I heard Lee Corso say one of the dumbest things I've heard in years. He said, and I quote, "Florida has an advantage against the Buckeyes because Ohio St. does NOT possess SEC speed at every position". Every year people disrespect Ohio St. with similar comments regarding their team speed and then after they take an L in a bowl game (ala Miami Fla 2002 & K. St. 2003) they come back and say, "we didn't realize OSU was THAT fast". Ummmm, do these teams not watch film of Ohio St. or something. Please explain this comment. I realize I am in the minority here but I foresee an extremely comfortable Buckeye W against UF
Mark Schlabach: I'd say Ted Ginn Jr. is pretty darn fast. Same for Wells and Pittman and those guys. I don't think Ohio State's speed is a concern. I'd love to see a 100-yard dash between Ginnn and Percy Harvin, though.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chad (Los Angeles, CA): Mark, I always hear that university presidents and ADs are the ones primarily opposed to a college football playoff. Why is it that they wouldn't want one?
Mark Schlabach: They say they don't want the season extended. Why are we waiting a month to play the bowl games that really matter? Could be playing them right now.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
pietro (G-Ville, FL): " Barring a miracle, Florida won't get to play for the national championship this season, even if the No. 4 Gators beat No. 8 Arkansas in Saturday night's SEC championship game in the Georgia Dome" looks like the miracle happened
Mark Schlabach: Yep, I didn't think UCLA had any shot at USC. I was wrong.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gil (Atlanta, GA): How come no one is talking about the Tressel & Lloyd comments before the Nov. 18th game. Both coaaches, when specifically asked, said they wanted THIS game (Nov. 18) to be the only one. There was to be "no rematch". All of the sudden I am getting flashbacks to Rocky I when Apollo Creed tells Rockey there "ain't gonna be no rematch" and Rocky says "I don't want one" and then low and behold Rocky II. We're now up to Rocky 6...
Mark Schlabach: Agreed. Everyone associated with that game said they didn't want a rematch -- until Michigan was left out.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JMO Toronto: I am sick of hearing the argument give Florida a shot at OSU. Why don't people pick who they feel are the two best teams in the nation.?
Mark Schlabach: I did. I thought Florida was second-best and that's what I wrote. But I don't vote.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
David (Gainesville FL): Now that a conference championship game helped Florida will we see the Big Ten or other BCS conferences expanding and implementing championship games to avoid what happened to Michigan?
Mark Schlabach: They should. Florida proved it can help you get into the BCS title game. Conversely, it also can hurt you and knock you out of the game. I always believed each of the BCS conferences should play a championship game. It evens the playing field.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jim Tressel: Columbus, Ohio: I haven't played for a while will that hurt me on Jan 8. Or are my guys just simply better than the gators. I didn't vote so I can't complain about who I play. P.S. No coaches should vote, it makes grown men sound like they are running for homecoming queen
Mark Schlabach: Don't think the layoff will be much of a factor. But don't discount Florida. They're very, very talented and have been very tested this season. Could see a repeat of '02 Ohio State team. Nobody gave the Buckeyes a chance against Miami.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Matt (Atlanta, GA): How bad Florida gets beat is directly proportional to how many mistakes Chris Leak makes, so how bad is it going to be?
Mark Schlabach: I really thought he was going to cost them the SEC championship game. He can't make mistakes against the Buckeyes. You know Troy Smith won't make many, if any.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
james (plantation, FL): Agree of Disagree. the real tragedy isn't that Florida is number two. the real tragedy occurred after Michigan lost to ohio state and remained # 2 in the BCS. how can that be justified?
Mark Schlabach: You said it. Not me.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Daniel: (Searcy, Ar): IF Florida beats Ohio State, and I mean IF, will people stop doubting that the SEC is the toughest conference in the nation?
Mark Schlabach: Would probably go a long way in doing that. No doubt the SEC is the best conference in the country. It ended up stronger than I thought it would be.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chris (Bloomington, IN): Mark please dont cop out like everyone else and answer this questions, how do you feel about the Heisman Trophy going to a player who was let off the hook by only being suspended 2 games when he accepted gifts from a booster?
Mark Schlabach: He received his punishment from the NCAA, sat out two games and earned the starting job. Kids make mistake. Troy Smith made his share, but he's stayed out of trouble since.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jason (Columbus, OH): While I do think that Florida deserves to be in the NC game, I think it was because the voters didn't want a rematch. My problem with Mich getting left out is that if no one wanted the rematch, Mich should've been ranked 4th after the loss to OSU.... What do you think?
Mark Schlabach: I don't vote. I've never liked the polls. Still don't. I never thought there should be a rematch. Michigan had its chance and lost. They didn't win the Big 10. I know that's not a requirement in getting to the BCS title game, but I just feel you should win your league. Florida won the toughest league in the country and finished with the same record as the Wolverines.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dylan:(Columbia,SC):: Hey how do you think Florida's defense will match up against the Ohio State ofense?
Mark Schlabach: Derrick Harvey and Jarvis Moss have to pressure Troy Smith and keep him from running to the corner. Linebackers should be better with Brandon Siler and Earl Everett getting some time to heal. Safety Reggie Nelson is as good as any defensive player in the country. Cornerback Ryan Smith is fundamentally sound and plays the ball really well. Cornerback Reggie Lewis struggled against the Razorbacks Saturday night, but has been OK this year. Florida is very good on defense. They've got a better defense than offense.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mike (Dallas): Mark, here's what UM fans are missing. Remove any anti-rematch agendas, and UF still has more wins, more Top 25 wins, much tougher schedule and the WON the title in the best conference. Michigan doesn't belong in the conversation with Florida - where am I wrong?
Mark Schlabach: Michigan definitely deserved to be in the BCS title game discussion. I think it was probably a toss-up, in fact. Wolverines lost to Ohio State. We don't know what Florida is going to do. Maybe they won't give up 42 points to the Buckeyes. Maybe they can't score 39. But on paper, I believe Florida had a much better argument because the Gators played a tougher schedule and won their conference.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________
Welcome to The Show! On Monday, ESPN.com's college football reporter Mark Schlabach will stop by to take your questions on the college gridiron. Schlabach joined ESPN.com in July 2006 as a college football and basketball columnist. A graduate of the University of Georgia, Mark spent nine years at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution covering Georgia and the SEC, as well as the NFL and NASCAR. Before joining ESPN, Schlabach spent the last two years at the Washington Post covering college football and basketball, and boxing.
Send your questions now and join Schlabach in The Show at 3 p.m. ET on Monday.
Mark Schlabach: OK, here we go. I'm sure we've got plenty to talk about today.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bruce (Greensboro, NC): I would like for you to comment on something. Last night, I heard Lee Corso say one of the dumbest things I've heard in years. He said, and I quote, "Florida has an advantage against the Buckeyes because Ohio St. does NOT possess SEC speed at every position". Every year people disrespect Ohio St. with similar comments regarding their team speed and then after they take an L in a bowl game (ala Miami Fla 2002 & K. St. 2003) they come back and say, "we didn't realize OSU was THAT fast". Ummmm, do these teams not watch film of Ohio St. or something. Please explain this comment. I realize I am in the minority here but I foresee an extremely comfortable Buckeye W against UF
Mark Schlabach: I'd say Ted Ginn Jr. is pretty darn fast. Same for Wells and Pittman and those guys. I don't think Ohio State's speed is a concern. I'd love to see a 100-yard dash between Ginnn and Percy Harvin, though.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chad (Los Angeles, CA): Mark, I always hear that university presidents and ADs are the ones primarily opposed to a college football playoff. Why is it that they wouldn't want one?
Mark Schlabach: They say they don't want the season extended. Why are we waiting a month to play the bowl games that really matter? Could be playing them right now.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
pietro (G-Ville, FL): " Barring a miracle, Florida won't get to play for the national championship this season, even if the No. 4 Gators beat No. 8 Arkansas in Saturday night's SEC championship game in the Georgia Dome" looks like the miracle happened
Mark Schlabach: Yep, I didn't think UCLA had any shot at USC. I was wrong.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gil (Atlanta, GA): How come no one is talking about the Tressel & Lloyd comments before the Nov. 18th game. Both coaaches, when specifically asked, said they wanted THIS game (Nov. 18) to be the only one. There was to be "no rematch". All of the sudden I am getting flashbacks to Rocky I when Apollo Creed tells Rockey there "ain't gonna be no rematch" and Rocky says "I don't want one" and then low and behold Rocky II. We're now up to Rocky 6...
Mark Schlabach: Agreed. Everyone associated with that game said they didn't want a rematch -- until Michigan was left out.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JMO Toronto: I am sick of hearing the argument give Florida a shot at OSU. Why don't people pick who they feel are the two best teams in the nation.?
Mark Schlabach: I did. I thought Florida was second-best and that's what I wrote. But I don't vote.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
David (Gainesville FL): Now that a conference championship game helped Florida will we see the Big Ten or other BCS conferences expanding and implementing championship games to avoid what happened to Michigan?
Mark Schlabach: They should. Florida proved it can help you get into the BCS title game. Conversely, it also can hurt you and knock you out of the game. I always believed each of the BCS conferences should play a championship game. It evens the playing field.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jim Tressel: Columbus, Ohio: I haven't played for a while will that hurt me on Jan 8. Or are my guys just simply better than the gators. I didn't vote so I can't complain about who I play. P.S. No coaches should vote, it makes grown men sound like they are running for homecoming queen
Mark Schlabach: Don't think the layoff will be much of a factor. But don't discount Florida. They're very, very talented and have been very tested this season. Could see a repeat of '02 Ohio State team. Nobody gave the Buckeyes a chance against Miami.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Matt (Atlanta, GA): How bad Florida gets beat is directly proportional to how many mistakes Chris Leak makes, so how bad is it going to be?
Mark Schlabach: I really thought he was going to cost them the SEC championship game. He can't make mistakes against the Buckeyes. You know Troy Smith won't make many, if any.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
james (plantation, FL): Agree of Disagree. the real tragedy isn't that Florida is number two. the real tragedy occurred after Michigan lost to ohio state and remained # 2 in the BCS. how can that be justified?
Mark Schlabach: You said it. Not me.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Daniel: (Searcy, Ar): IF Florida beats Ohio State, and I mean IF, will people stop doubting that the SEC is the toughest conference in the nation?
Mark Schlabach: Would probably go a long way in doing that. No doubt the SEC is the best conference in the country. It ended up stronger than I thought it would be.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chris (Bloomington, IN): Mark please dont cop out like everyone else and answer this questions, how do you feel about the Heisman Trophy going to a player who was let off the hook by only being suspended 2 games when he accepted gifts from a booster?
Mark Schlabach: He received his punishment from the NCAA, sat out two games and earned the starting job. Kids make mistake. Troy Smith made his share, but he's stayed out of trouble since.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jason (Columbus, OH): While I do think that Florida deserves to be in the NC game, I think it was because the voters didn't want a rematch. My problem with Mich getting left out is that if no one wanted the rematch, Mich should've been ranked 4th after the loss to OSU.... What do you think?
Mark Schlabach: I don't vote. I've never liked the polls. Still don't. I never thought there should be a rematch. Michigan had its chance and lost. They didn't win the Big 10. I know that's not a requirement in getting to the BCS title game, but I just feel you should win your league. Florida won the toughest league in the country and finished with the same record as the Wolverines.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dylan:(Columbia,SC):: Hey how do you think Florida's defense will match up against the Ohio State ofense?
Mark Schlabach: Derrick Harvey and Jarvis Moss have to pressure Troy Smith and keep him from running to the corner. Linebackers should be better with Brandon Siler and Earl Everett getting some time to heal. Safety Reggie Nelson is as good as any defensive player in the country. Cornerback Ryan Smith is fundamentally sound and plays the ball really well. Cornerback Reggie Lewis struggled against the Razorbacks Saturday night, but has been OK this year. Florida is very good on defense. They've got a better defense than offense.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mike (Dallas): Mark, here's what UM fans are missing. Remove any anti-rematch agendas, and UF still has more wins, more Top 25 wins, much tougher schedule and the WON the title in the best conference. Michigan doesn't belong in the conversation with Florida - where am I wrong?
Mark Schlabach: Michigan definitely deserved to be in the BCS title game discussion. I think it was probably a toss-up, in fact. Wolverines lost to Ohio State. We don't know what Florida is going to do. Maybe they won't give up 42 points to the Buckeyes. Maybe they can't score 39. But on paper, I believe Florida had a much better argument because the Gators played a tougher schedule and won their conference.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------