His stats across the board havent varied much the last 4 years. He had the fewest TDs of his career his freshman year. Most INT's his Soph year.
The rest of the stats are pretty consistent.
Losses never fall on just one player.
Your offense wasn't all that special that year, so I'd say a true freshman QB contributed to that.
We can't have a true freshman who is underweight start for us in a make-or-break year for our HC when we have a more than capable senior on the roster.