Jump to content

2015 SECTalk.com Fundraiser
Progress: $1,100 of $2,570 raised

SEC Football Articles

Latest Topics


Stay Connected

Rate Article  - - - - -

SEC Power Rankings - Post-season




1. Alabama - Any questions? Alabama eliminates all detractors this season, as they play again for the national championship, but this time having legitimately won their division and the SECCG. It was a war in Atlanta, but at the end the Tide were victorious, and stand at the top yet once more. One hurdle remains - #1 Notre Dame - to their second consecutive National Championship.

2. Georgia - if there were any out there who questioned the legitimacy of this Bulldog team, those questions were likely answered. Georgia lost on Saturday night, but the effort put forth was unquestionably championship-caliber. UGA stood toe to toe with the top program in college football and traded punches to the last second of the contest. For the Bulldogs, coming up four yards short of their ultimate goal was a heartbreaking defeat. But going forward, most Georgia fans feel pretty good at the direction the program Mark Richt is taking the program.. The Bulldogs will look to finish strong to put themselves in good position next pre-season with a victory over #16 Nebraska.

3. Florida - For the Gators, a Sugar Bowl bid will be the reward for their fine season in which they accomplished more than most thought they would in a year where their offense struggled at times. Outstanding defensive play and no frills physical run play were the keys to their 11 win season, and in the end, that's what this conference is about. The Gators probably won't be tested by Louisville in the Sugar Bowl.

4.  LSU - Favorites to start the year, the Tigers couldn't quite overcome some of their losses on the defensive side of the ball and achieve the expectations that were set for them. But despite that, still a top 10 team that could beat most teams in the country. Zach Mettenberger has room to improve, which is a plus. Tigers could end the season with positive momentum with a thrashing of Clemson in the Chick-fil-A Bowl.

5. Texas A&M - It seems almost wrong to put the only team that beat Alabama this low, but somebody has to go here. Aggie fans have to wonder how things would have worked out if they had an easier opponent in week 2 of the season than Florida. Still, remarkable inaugural season for this team and for Johnny Manziel, who is probably a lock to win the Heisman, and the Aggies get to showcase him in the Cotton Bowl versus old foe Oklahoma.

6. South Carolina - Another strong season for Spurrier's Gamecocks, just not quite good enough. A lack of consistency hurt this team more than anything this season. There were times they looked like the best team in the conference and times when they looked like a different team altogether. But again, another top 10 SEC team, 5th in their own conference. Gamecocks could have won two other BCS conferences with this team - just not the SEC. I should note that I'd have the Gamecocks another spot up if they still had Lattimore healthy right now. Without him I have them one spot lower.

7. Vanderbilt - Highlighting the "best of the rest" category are the somewhat surprising Vanderbilt Commodores. James Franklin has earned a rightful share of respect for leading Vandy to an 8-4 victory and the Music City Bowl. He says he'll be at Vandy for a long time - but will bigger names come calling if he keeps this up?

8. Ole Miss - I thought Hugh Freeze should have been seriously considered as coach of the year. Most considered Ole Miss a long shot to win more than 2-3 games this year, and none had them winning any conference games. Yet they finish 6-6, with three SEC wins, an Egg Bowl victory and headed to a bowl game! You've got to respect what they did with what most called a "bare cupboard" in Oxford.

9. Mississippi State - For most Bully fans, this season was a bit unsatisfying. They steamed through the early part of their schedule without much trouble but just didn't look impressive very often in the second half. 8-4 isn't a bad season, but dropping four of their last five games isn't going to make anyone in Starkville feel good about next year.

10. Missouri - Not the campaign the Tigers wanted in year one of the SEC, but a learning experience no doubt. Mizzou has already let their OC resign and will no doubt look to build an offense next year that can keep them competitive in 2013.

11. Arkansas - Hog fans are grateful this season is over and that they can now look forward to seeing what new coach Bret Bielema will have in store for them next year.

12. Tennessee - A disappointing year for Tennessee fans who believe that offensively they'd have enough success to possibly get to 8 wins. Instead, a 5-7 overall record is their result and their shopping for a new coach. Exciting times are ahead though, as all new hires bring with them eager anticipation of what's to come.

13. Auburn - It was shocking how far the mighty fell in such a short time, but that's exactly what happened on the Plains. Auburn Tigers, nat'l champs two years ago now winless in the SEC and 3-9 overall. But, they've kicked out Chizik, and re-called Malzahn. Meet the new boss... same as the old boss?

14. Kentucky - You could really interchange these last two. There was nothing good about UK football in 2012, but Cats fans are all looking forward to the new regime under Mark Stoops to see if he can get them competitive in 2013.





Final Thoughts: It's been pretty crazy just how clearly defined the upper and lower tier of the conference was this season. With very few exceptions, the top six has remained isolated from the lower 8 for the majority of the year. I can't remember a time when there was such a drop-off between the top and the bottom, but I can't remember ever a time when six SEC teams finished the season ranked in the BCS top 10, either.

I appreciate you all taking the time to read and comment on these power rankings throughout the season, I know we've had a lot of fun and heated debate with them. I look forward to doing them again next year.


77 Comments

Swap LSU & aTm & I agree
Tennessee was the best offensive team in the conference and lead the conference in total offense.

Think about that for a second.

View Postbmccall, on 04 December 2012 - 06:10 PM, said:

Tennessee was the best offensive team in the conference and lead the conference in total offense.

Think about that for a second.

Kentucky was 6-6 2 years ago when Mike Hartline was the QB and he put up some good numbers and we were one of the top offensive teams in the SEC but consequently we were already DOWN by like 3 TD's when we started to put up the numbers.  Tennessee is probably similar in this route but also probably were turnover prone.

View PostShow Stopper, on 04 December 2012 - 06:16 PM, said:

Kentucky was 6-6 2 years ago when Mike Hartline was the QB and he put up some good numbers and we were one of the top offensive teams in the SEC but consequently we were already DOWN by like 3 TD's when we started to put up the numbers.  Tennessee is probably similar in this route but also probably were turnover prone.

I've watched Tennessee play a lot this year. Their OL was second to possibly only Alabama (if the team wasn't so awful, could have easily took an Alabama slot or two on the OL AA selections). They put up points on us, Georgia, Florida, etc. Much less all who watched this game especially earlier in the season that their receivers had a hard time making wide open catches. I remember a huge one early in the Florida game.

These are good secondaries. Especially Florida and Georgia's secondaries.
Alabama too low.

Georgia too high.

Everything else looks about right.

View Postdcbl, on 04 December 2012 - 06:05 PM, said:

Swap LSU & aTm & I agree

They did beat aTm so I am okay with their placement.
If power rankings are based off of the last performance, and a person looks at it with a totally unbiased opinion, then aTm is the undisputed #1.

I'd say,

aTm
Bama
Georgia
Florida
LSU

etc, etc...

Doubt anyone could beat A&M the way they're playing now.
Bigger names have come calling. Franklin's at Vandy for the long haul.

View Postbmccall, on 04 December 2012 - 06:20 PM, said:

I've watched Tennessee play a lot this year. Their OL was second to possibly only Alabama (if the team wasn't so awful, could have easily took an Alabama slot or two on the OL AA selections).
These are good secondaries. Especially Florida and Georgia's secondaries.

OL at ATM  has Tenessee beat. Two 1st rounders. The OL is big part of the reason Johnny looked so good.

View PostABQAG, on 04 December 2012 - 10:12 PM, said:



The OL is big part of the reason Johnny looked so good.

Agree to disagree on this
This is awesome. We are #8 out of 14 teams with a 6-6 record. Moved up from where we were last sept too.
Kentucky >>> Auburn

My decision based upon the new HC hire.
I really think people are overvaluing Alabama this year.
They are probably the best team in the country, but they aren't nearly as good as their last two title winners.

2-6 is interchangeable.
I also think it's ridiculous that because Georgia played Bama to the final seconds people think UGA is some powerhouse now.
A&M beat them and they needed a last second drive against LSU to win that one.

View PostJoeGator, on 05 December 2012 - 09:31 AM, said:

I really think people are overvaluing Alabama this year.
They are probably the best team in the country, but they aren't nearly as good as their last two titles winners.

2-6 is interchangeable.
I also think it's ridiculous that because Georgia played Bama to the final seconds people think UGA is some powerhouse now because they came close.
A&M beat them and they needed a last second drive against LSU to win that one.

Sour Grapes. You cannot convince me that Florida should be ahead of UGA. Taking the best team in the nation to the buzzer is the definition of second best lol.

View PostHothotz, on 05 December 2012 - 09:34 AM, said:

Sour Grapes. You cannot convince me that Florida should be ahead of UGA. Taking the best team in the nation to the buzzer is the definition of second best lol.
Just to play Devils' Advocate, what about beating the best team in the nation (Texas A&M)?.  And yes, I know they have 2 losses.

And for the record, I agree with UGA at #2 and Bama at #1.  The only reason I bring this up is I don't fully agree with what you stated in red.  It's more of a "total picture" decision IMO.
man oh man.............the Tide plays LSU......in death valley.......at nite........a team who hates the Tide and wanted revenge like a mofo.....Mettenburger plays out of his mind..........and we win but its a Posted Imageing knock against us?

the Tide plays a Georgia team that is a leader in offense and hell bent on winning and if not for a bs tipped ball call, we wouldve won handily but won anyway....and its a Posted Imagein knock against us?

the Tide plays the hottest team in college football led by the Heisman winner, gets behind in 1st quarter but holds them to 9 pts and 90 yards in the 2nd half and loses on the final play and the Tide sux?

this shit is better than reading the comics

View PostGAMECOCK_FAN, on 05 December 2012 - 09:37 AM, said:

Just to play Devils' Advocate, what about beating the best team in the nation (Texas A&M)?.  And yes, I know they have 2 losses.

And for the record, I agree with UGA at #2.

You have to take records into account. If we didn't we wouldn't get anywhere.

Texas A&M beats Bama
Bama beat LSU
LSU beat USC
USC beat UGA
UGA beat Florida
Florida beat Texas A&M

View PostHaymaker, on 05 December 2012 - 09:39 AM, said:

man oh man.............the Tide plays LSU......in death valley.......at nite........a team who hates the Tide and wanted revenge like a mofo.....Mettenburger plays out of his mind..........and we win but its a :lanekiffin:ing knock against us?

the Tide plays a Georgia team that is a leader in offense and hell bent on winning and if not for a bs tipped ball call, we wouldve won handily but won anyway....and its a :lanekiffin:in knock against us?

the Tide plays the hottest team in college football led by the Heisman winner, gets behind in 1st quarter but holds them to 9 pts and 90 yards in the 2nd half and loses on the final play and the Tide sux?

this shit is better than reading the comics

Your bitching about being First.........LOL.

Your more delusional about Bama then Hobby i about Georgia.

View PostHothotz, on 05 December 2012 - 09:43 AM, said:

You have to take records into account. If we didn't we wouldn't get anywhere.

Texas A&M beats Bama
Bama beat LSU
LSU beat USC
USC beat UGA
UGA beat Florida
Florida beat Texas A&M
See the second part that I added in my post (must have been editing it when you quoted my post).  I agree that it's a total picture decision (e.g., records, etc.), but I didn't agree with your statement in red.  You made it sound like UGA should be 2nd based only on taking Bama to the wire.

View PostGAMECOCK_FAN, on 05 December 2012 - 09:45 AM, said:

See the second part that I added in my post (must have been editing it when you quoted my post).  I agree that it's a total picture decision (e.g., records, etc.), but I didn't agree with your statement in red.  You made it sound like UGA should be 2nd based only on taking Bama to the wire.

These are power rankings. They are week to week. We lost by mere yards and seconds to the best team in college football. That's second place. If we had backed our way into the title game then I would agree more information would be needed to place teams in a certain spot. There is no justifiable reason for any team jumping us over our performance against the Tide.

View PostHothotz, on 05 December 2012 - 09:47 AM, said:

These are power rankings. They are week to week. We lost by mere yards and seconds to the best team in college football. That's second place. If we had backed our way into the title game then I would agree more information would be needed to place teams in a certain spot. There is no justifiable reason for any team jumping us over our performance against the Tide.
Like I said, I agree with UGA at #2.  Just not completely with your rationale in your original post.  I think even with Power Rankings you have to look at a little more than a week, especially when only two teams played that week.  I would have had UGA #2 prior and kept them there as well.  No biggy.

View PostGAMECOCK_FAN, on 05 December 2012 - 09:57 AM, said:

Like I said, I agree with UGA at #2.  Just not completely with your rationale in your original post.  I think even with Power Rankings you have to look at a little more than a week, especially when only two teams played that week.  I would have had UGA #2 prior and kept them there as well.  No biggy.

Whats your reasoning for UGA at 2? Even if we went week to week the last time we lost was to you guys. Which at that point in time I was ready to rank UGA just below Kentucky.

View PostHothotz, on 05 December 2012 - 09:58 AM, said:

Whats your reasoning for UGA at 2? Even if we went week to week the last time we lost was to you guys. Which at that point in time I was ready to rank UGA just below Kentucky.
I would have had them at #2 behind Bama prior to the SECCG based on winning the East, one loss, and playing very well the last 3-4 weeks.  I still believed Bama was the best team in the SEC even after their loss against Texas A&M and hence Bama #1.  Some people consider the Power Rankings based only on a week (which is how HNB has defined it I believe).  If I'm going to rank teams I can't go entirely on a week and have to look at other things as well.  Power rankings are subjective so it's not a big deal IMO.

View PostGAMECOCK_FAN, on 05 December 2012 - 10:04 AM, said:

I would have had them at #2 behind Bama prior to the SECCG based on winning the East, one loss, and playing very well the last 3-4 weeks.  I still believed Bama was the best team in the SEC even after their loss against Texas A&M and hence Bama #1.  Some people consider the Power Rankings based only on a week (which is how HNB has defined it I believe).  If I'm going to rank teams I can't go entirely on a week and have to look at other things as well.  Power rankings are subjective so it's not a big deal IMO.

Yeah well I nominated u for mod of the year so you have to agree with me lol :P
I think you could take any of the top 6 teams and on a given day they could defeat the other. Somedays are just not your day and it is all about when you play, who can play, and where you play.  It is great to be a Gamecock!